40 Creative {Non-Candy} Easter Egg Fillers

Easter is sneaking around the corner like a white fluffy tail! You know what that means, mamas! Filling Easter eggs and baskets! As I’m preparing for the big egg hunt, my mind immediately hops back to our family candy bowl.

Because it is FULL, you guys!

In fact, that ceramic vessel is practically over-flowing with sweet treats from past holidays dating all the way back to Halloween of 2016!  Truthfully, our daughter just doesn’t eat that much candy. While our stash has dwindled, the one putting a dent in it has really been yours truly

As a result, this year I am looking to fill the Easter eggs with mainly non-edible items. I have spent the last couple of weeks brainstorming and scouting around town for some creative, fun gifts to fill the eggs that the kids will love, even if they are sugar-free! 

40 Creative non-candy Easter Egg Fillers

Arts and Craft Supplies

  • Paint
  • Stickers
  • Glitter Glue
  • Chalk
  • Washi Tape
  • Erasers
  • Spring shaped crayons
  • Stamps

Party Store Trinkets

  • Bouncy Balls
  • Bubbles
  • Punch Balloons
  • Wind Up Toys
  • Temporary Tattoos
  • Sticky Hands/Darts
  • Whistles/Noisemakers

Costume and Dress Up Accessories

  • Plastic Jewelry
  • Mini Princess Tiaras
  • Pirate Eye Patch
  • Gold Doubloons 
  • Stick on Mustaches
  • Ninja Masks
  • Sheriff Badge

Tiny Toys

  • Hot Wheels/Toy Cars
  • Shopkins
  • Small Figurines
  • Puzzle Pieces
  • Silly Putty 
  • Tsum Tsums 
  • Plastic Bugs/Critters
  • Green Army Men
  • Legos
  • Finger Puppets

Non-Toy Fun Things

I found several of these ideas and items for Easter egg fillers at places like the Dollar Tree and Party City. Of course, it is always fun to peruse the dollar bins and party sections of big box stores for other creative, affordable finds!

Now, if you don’t have time for all that, but don’t want your littles to miss out on the fun, be sure to snatch tickets to CRMB’s Easter Eggstravagnza on April 8th! 

Make sure you never miss out on a parenting or community-related blog postsign up to receive CRMB posts in your inbox.  While you’re at it, join our VIP List to ensure you’re one of the first to know about upcoming Cedar Rapids Moms Blog events and promotions!!


Mina works as a cake decorator in Cedar Rapids, where she resides with her little family of three. Although she was born and raised in small town Illinois, she’s always been an Iowa girl at heart and planted roots in Des Moines shortly after graduating as a Cornjerker. It was there she met the love of her life, Dale! They quickly added their sweet and sassy daughter to the mix in August 2013. Mina dove head-first into being Eisley’s mommy and loves embracing the happiness and curiosity of childhood with her. In her free time she loves writing, eating, getting in some family time and binge watching TV dramas.